I didn't mean to.
Nov. 10th, 2007 01:34 pm
evilgrins posted at
doctorwho yesterday contending that the Doctor tends to kidnap his companions, compiling a list from memory. For twenty-four hours I resisted compiling a rebuttal, but I fell.
It's difficult for me to say the Doctor kidnaps anyone, since as a rule - at least before the Time War - he resists taking on a new companion as hard as he can. Often they are intentional or unintentional stowaways.
- Doctor One
- We didn't see his granddaughter Susan board the TARDIS. She may have stowed away or not.
- He took off with Barbara and Ian aboard as an alternative to allowing them to report his presence to the 1963 authorities.
- He took Vicki aboard as the only alternative to leaving an underage girl alone on an alien planet.
- Steven stowed away.
- If I ever knew details of Katarina's boarding or Sara Kingdom's boarding I've forgotten them.
- Dodo was welcomed aboard, as the possible descendant of someone the Doctor wanted to think hadn't died two hundred years before, and because she looked like Susan.
- Ben and Polly climbed aboard just before a takeoff because they wondered why the Doctor went into a police box.
- Jamie is goaded into boarding the TARDIS just before it departs by one or more of its current crew, but I don't know by whom.
- Victoria is another Susan-surrogate, having lost her father to the Daleks.
- Zoe is brought aboard only after being compelled to watch a video of the adventure when Victoria lost her father.
- Liz never set foot aboard the TARDIS that we know. (Of course, that was the year it never moved.)
- Jo was invited into the TARDIS only after the Doctor had got to know her over three adventures already.
- The Brigadier and Benton only boarded the TARDIS under emergency circumstances.
- Sarah Jane snuck aboard.
- Harry was invited on as a practical joke.
- Leela invited herself on against the Doctor's express wishes.
- Romana was put aboard by the White Guardian against the Doctor's express wishes.
- Adric stowed away.
- Nyssa met up with the Doctor on Logopolis ostensibly only to get help finding her missing father, but then the Master destroyed her planet.
- Tegan boarded the TARDIS thinking it was a police box.
- Turlough boarded the TARDIS with ulterior motives.
- Peri was brought aboard by Turlough in emergency circumstances.
- Non-causal loop aside, we don't know how Mel originally boarded the TARDIS.
- It was Mel's idea, not the Doctor's, that Ace board the TARDIS.
- The Doctor asked Grace to board the TARDIS but she declined.
- Rose was the first to be asked to board the TARDIS twice.
- The Doctor asked Mickey aboard but he declined.
- Rose asked Adam aboard over the Doctor's objections.
- The Doctor asked Jack aboard as an alternative to allowing Jack to die after proving his worth.
- The Doctor asked Rose a third time, being uncertain she still wanted to after he regenerated.
- The Doctor and Rose asked Sarah Jane to come with them, but when they get Mickey instead Rose was more put out than the Doctor.
- The Doctor asked Donna along, but she found him scary.
- The Doctor strung Martha along with several just-one-more trips until finally admitting she was "never just a passenger".
- The Doctor and the TARDIS both ran as hard as they could from Jack, but under special circumstances.
- Spoiler for next season We don't know yet the circumstances surrounding the boardings of next season's companions, all return companions: Donna, Martha, and (according to the latest shooting news) Jack.
no subject
Date: 2007-11-11 04:34 am (UTC)According to Business Unusual, Mel stowed away.
Several of the times you've mentioned there (Tegan, Peri) it was a sort of unintentional kidnapping... I note that he didn't seem to make any attempt to return Peri back to Earth, and she didn't seem to mind anyway.